Simply skimmed this for the primary time because it got here it, yikes. It is arduous to recollect what I considered it then. I agree that it is held up properly. I’ve largely internalized the old-school model, for video games that help it, though I am not fairly versus character talent checks. One cause is that in lots of techniques, trying talent checks is the best way you get higher at them. So if it is “all participant talent, on a regular basis,” then your character does not enhance. Not a difficulty in d20ish techniques the place character development comes by means of treasure extraction.
The opposite cause is that many techniques provide extra gamey methods to push and prod the fiction relying in your talent verify. Genesys is one in style instance. In the event you solely use participant talent, then you definately’ll by no means introduce benefit/drawback, and so forth.