Tremendous-Detailed Evaluate Of Pimax Sword Controllers!

Manufacturing facility Data*

• Manufacturing facility Location: No. 3000 Longdong Avenue, Pudongxin District, Metropolis space, Shanghai, China Shanghai
• Variety of Employees: 51 – 100 Individuals

*This appears to have modified because the manufacturing deal with on the controller field was the “New Technology Data Know-how Park in Rizhao, Shandong”.

From studying among the commerce data for Shandong, there are a number of parks of high-technology corporations endeavor analysis and growth, and high-tech manufacturing. These know-how parks have been partly funded as a part of a Authorities-backed initative to extend growth and manufacturing of XR gear in key areas throughout China. 

Pimax has talked about up to now utilizing industry-leading distributors with the flexibility to scale, but it surely’s unclear whether or not Pimax operates its personal facility or makes use of a companion vendor. However the Sword controllers appear to be coming from one in all these high-tech factories in Rizhao.

Pimax shortly established a reputation for its VR headsets which pushed the boundaries of show know-how with excessive resolutions and excessive body charges mixed with the widest subject of view accessible in available shopper headsets.

Following the profitable growth of 2K and 4K prototypes, the product launches of 4K and 5K headsets, by November of 2016 Pimax had constructed its formidable 8K prototype. This fast iteration is one thing that Pimax is understood for, not unusual in on-shore tech enterprise tradition with entry to specialist manufacturing services, skilled engineers, and samples of the very newest parts. Issues transfer in a short time, competitors is all the time pressuring, there is no such thing as a time to hold about…

September 2017 noticed the launch of its 8K Kickstarter marketing campaign with quite a few bonus tiers together with three headset fashions, lighthouse base stations, knuckle fashion controllers with trackpads or joysticks, completely different head straps with audio choices, cooling followers, wi-fi transmitter, eye-tracking module, and hand monitoring module to call among the bewildering choices.

Following an especially profitable marketing campaign, the undertaking reached $4,236,618 from 5,946 backers (the preliminary funding objective was $200,000) however as with many Kickstarter initiatives, there have been some delays and different points.

Some backers complained about lengthy delays, issues getting monitoring numbers, headsets delivery with out base stations (throughout manufacturing drought), lengthy waits for controllers, and reviews of headset casings cracking, amongst the standard QA issues with early manufacturing. There have been additionally reviews of sluggish guarantee help, some miscommunication issues, software program glitches, compatibility points with sure graphics card, and many others.

Customer support and QA points aren’t unusual when a smaller firm out of the blue finds itself going through an enormous problem, backed by the cash of many various clients from all around the World.

Its unclear in the end how lots of the backer targets have been ever absolutely delivered, however from studying on-line suggestions following the Kickstarter, typically the purchasers appeared pleased with their headsets and different equipment. 

It takes plenty of onerous work to construct an excellent fame, and Pimax appears to be making strides ahead however there’ll stay an excellent quantity of people that stay unconvinced both from direct expertise or having learn an excessive amount of unfavorable press across the Kickstarter.

For varied causes, Pimax had by no means had a lot beneficial protection from the mainstream VR press. Some testers had tried earlier fashions, experiencing distortion or illness, placing them off making an attempt once more regardless of massive enhancements being made in later fashions.

To be truthful to Pimax, rising pains are typical when scaling up any firm. Add to it the Kickstarter marketing campaign; combine with a gaggle of enthusiastic testers and a really vocal group eager to go ultra-wide as quickly as potential… it’s not shocking that Pimax boards have been usually noisy and the mods busy.

Additionally, there actually isn’t anybody else pushing the ultra-wide PCVR know-how so onerous, while making it accessible for shopper buy, in contrast to earlier ultra-wide enterprise-only gear that few ever bought to strive.

And let’s give them some credit score, Pimax 8K was an formidable undertaking that they did find yourself just about pulling off; delivering 8K headsets to many backers, fibre optic cables, audio head straps, face cushions, and many others. adopted by Valve equipped base stations, some Valve Index controllers and now their very own Sword controllers.

Pimax has persevered with enhancing their manufacturing, with their newest equipment really trying fairly good by way of options, supplies and ending.

New “Imaginative and prescient Sequence” blue headset casings are proving strong, normal high quality management enhancements have been made, along with ongoing software program updates, new face cushions, head straps, and audio options. Pimax has been tremendous busy while different PCVR distributors have considerably stagnated: Valve by no means launched a wi-fi adapter for the Index, and HTC shoe-horned the Focus 3’s lenses and shows into the outdated Vive Professional physique with combined outcomes.

Newer Imaginative and prescient 8K headset fashions have already arrived with their newest extra-aural audio resolution, while the following era of “Crystal” and “12K” at the moment are being closely promoted, with thrilling promotional supplies displaying some nice future potential. As soon as once more, the group is getting excited, and other people might be trying to trade-in their present headsets with a particular voucher supply that Pimax has made accessible.

Nevertheless, this fixed cycle of growth generally is a double edge sword (pun supposed) making it extra complicated for customers to know key product variations, while earlier points are maybe by no means absolutely resolved, as progress retains pushing ahead at a relentless tempo.

It’s additionally a distinct kind of enterprise tradition that may alienate some Western clients, however with Pimax concentrating on the tremendous high-end VR fanatics, this tempo of change and gross sales strategy was much less of a priority, and extra one thing the group appears to truly welcome.

However for a lot of VR customers, even the very long time PCVR avid gamers, it’s nonetheless a model on the extra excessive finish, and one which many appear reluctant to even strive; is it a concern of the unknown maybe mixed with the earlier on-line drama that performed out across the Kickstarter? Google searches are very revealing..

Nevertheless, their latest partnership with Amazon ought to take away any considerations associated to efficiency, becoming, or high quality with a free return coverage permitting you to purchase and take a look at with out the danger of getting caught with {hardware} that doesn’t be just right for you. As with every wearable gear, you gained’t know till you strive, and your likelihood of getting an excellent match will range.

Amazon supplied a problem free return for my Vive Professional 2 headset again after I simply couldn’t get it to suit correctly with out making what would have been warranty-busting modifications. Having used this mechanism to purchase with confidence, I’d be more than pleased to make use of Amazon to purchase any Pimax gear.

So regardless of what I’d learn and heard over the previous couple of years, my interplay with Pimax has been very constructive, discovering them way more responsive than the larger VR gamers.  From studying a few of their backstory it appears that evidently they’ve introduced new employees on board, closely invested in customer support opened warehouses on every continent, and have a brand new manufacturing facility.

They even have buyer help telephone numbers, which may be very uncommon in as of late of chatbots and emails, an important transfer to spice up buyer confidence. The hyperlink up with Amazon can also be nice for confidence when making what’s an costly product buy with no likelihood to demo at a retailer. Amazon additionally appears to be dealing with Pimax returns as I discovered later within the check.  

Pimax are trying set to turn out to be a severe VR participant, their fame can solely additional enhance with new administration and new merchandise. In the course of the writing of this text, Pimax has even relaunched its web site www.pimax.com which is an enormous enchancment with regard to the earlier model, and encompasses a a lot cleaner design with much less “vibrant” pop-up particular provides and offers.

If the web site is any indication of their new course, good issues are taking place at Pimax.  I used to be lucky sufficient to ask some questions of their COO Kevin Henderson, with our interview featured on the finish of this text. 

Welcome to Sword

What’s within the field? A pair of Sword controllers, a pair of Li-ion batteries in plastic circumstances, and a pair of USB leads in order that the batteries may be charged while inserted within the controllers, or the controllers given firmware updates by plugging into the PC.

The field itself was very sturdy with a thick foam core containing cut-outs that did their greatest to stop the controllers from being eliminated. This field also needs to survive any transit impacts, ensuring your Sword controllers arrive in the perfect situation. 

The brand new design was actually completely different, a primary look a mutant offspring of the brand new PSVR2 controller and an Oculus Contact. Nevertheless, as I used to be quickly to find, this was an unfair assumption as Pimax had labored by a substantial variety of iterations to succeed in their manufacturing design. Proven under are prototype controllers from the 8K kickstarter compaign, which appear like a joystick modified Vive wand.

Sword is actually an up to date Vive “Wand” controller with some key enhancements together with the hand strap and facet grip buttons, though the variety of inputs and enter varieties is restricted by the Vive Wand driver that it’s utilizing in SteamVR.

The Vive controller was by no means designed to offer analog joystick help or extra management face buttons, an issue that Pimax bumped into throughout growth, and is talked about within the interview on the finish of this text.

The picture under reveals the important thing options that Pimax have listed. I weighed every controller to double-check the accuracy of their 230g declare and located that the Left controller was 237g while the suitable was 234g, which is a standard variation seen in manufacturing.

This weight is with batteries fitted, coming in slightly heavier than my Index controllers which weigh 222g for left, and 223g for proper, together with 3D printed “palm boosters” (normal Index controller is round 195g).

Battery

Pimax selected detachable and replaceable batteries for the Sword. These are a typical “Sony kind” referred to as BXP-01 utilized in many digital cameras. 

Lithium ion Sort X rechargeable battery

• Approx. capability: 3.6V / 4.5Wh (1240mAh)
• Approx. dimensions (mm): W29.9 x H9.2 x D42.7
• Approx weight: 25g

The batteries may be charged while mounted within the controllers, or charged externally utilizing a mains charger. It took round 1 hour to cost each batteries I had purchased from Amazon within the included charging cradle, which was plugged right into a mains-powered smartphone charger I had spare at residence.

Its very straightforward to insert the batteries incorrectly (examine the contact pins): my batteries had the textual content going through outwards, for those who do insert the unsuitable means round (or again to entrance) you simply gained’t get any energy (clearly) however I’ve seen a couple of Youtubers make this error and initally assume the controllers wouldn’t work due to a fault.

Battery life was round 3 hours, with the sunshine on the Sword controllers finally turning crimson after which turning off. Battery life appeared depending on the appliance’s use of haptics, with video games like Beat Saber draining the batteries extra shortly than a soothing meditation app.  The batteries are retained contained in the physique with a small sprung clip, and the physique sealed with magnetic grip covers – these labored rather well and by no means got here unfastened in contrast to Oculus second era of Contact controlllers.

The battery elimination requires a slight re-design, as a result of there’s nothing to help the consumer in eradicating the batteries. Usually, producers embrace a small material strap that sits beneath the battery and by greedy the top can be utilized to drag the battery up for elimination.

With Sword, there’s a small sprung tab, however this wants working while the battery is being lifted. I ended up utilizing the deal with of a small kitchen spoon to softly prise the battery out while making an attempt to launch the sprung tab on the identical time. I can see this tab changing into broken over time, Pimax would profit from having a cloth strip below the battery on future fashions of Sword. 

Battery life was undoubtedly shorter than for Vive and Index controllers which each have non-removable batteries: that is the trade-off of utilizing a detachable widespread kind battery because the BXP battery itself is a hard and fast measurement / form, and requires a retention crade contained in the controller physique.

This cradle reduces inner quantity, while the oblong battery is extra awkward to package deal inside a controller; a customized “pouch” battery may be designed to suit a smaller or odd form inner house, giving a helpful improve in capability for longer play classes.

Pimax point out a battery “sizzling swap” function with a small fastened battery (or capacitor?) inside every controller permitting the primary battery to be eliminated with out the controller shedding energy and disconnecting from the session. Contemplating I simply used the controllers till the batteries ran flat, after which eliminated the batteries to fast cost, this wasn’t a function I examined or used.

The usage of detachable batteries is an total massive bonus as a result of it prevents the controller changing into ineffective after repeated use. It’s not unusual to see Redditors speaking about learn how to change depleted Index controller batteries, while Meta caught with removeable batteries from the primary Contact controller onwards. So while the play time per cost is shorter, total the detachable battery is an effective factor, particularly for the surroundings as prevents in any other case workable controllers from being scrapped (the E-Waste difficulty).

Lastly while in SteamVR I seen that the render mannequin of the Sword didn’t present any battery life (Index controllers present this clearly) however the knowledge is on the market as the appliance FPS VR reveals battery life for every controller. It might be price Pimax implementing this function because it’s helpful for shortly gauging energy with out having to enter FPS VR every time.

Pairing to SteamVR

Pairing the controller may be very straightforward. Simply pair in steamVR, no want for PiTools (although that is wanted for updates). SteamVR acknowledged each the Index and Pimax controllers and was blissful to work with both just by turning off the controllers and turning on the choice set. I didn’t must pair them every time, which was very helpful when evaluating the completely different controllers towards one another in video games.

Nevertheless, SteamVR was its glitchy self infrequently: throughout my final play session, I used to be utilizing Index controllers, which appeared to have the Sword render fashions nonetheless related. After turning off the controllers and turning again on, these up to date to Index render fashions, although I may see the render mannequin for the suitable Pimax controller sitting about 10 toes to the suitable facet of my playspace. Utilizing the “unpair all” command in Lighthouse console ought to remedy this, although the controllers would wish pairing once more afterwards.

Render Mannequin

As quickly as I began SteamVR and went into the steamVR residence surroundings, the Pimax render fashions have been seen. These regarded fairly easy with out detailed textures or animations.

The render fashions don’t function battery indicators (as beforehand talked about) however additionally include no animation for management inputs. After 3 years of Index controllers, this looks as if a step again, once you push a button you see a corresponding animation motion which is neat and provides to emotions of hand presence.

With the Sword controllers there is no such thing as a response, however in the end this doesn’t actually matter, and because the render mannequin is usually solely seen in steamVR residence (or when pausing an utility), it’s debatable Pimax properly spent their growth sources elsewhere.  A extra polished render mannequin with textures and animations is good, however maybe not mandatory (consider it as a “polish”). Let’s say that it does the job, however may very well be extra polished.

So what’s going on right here then? Fast overview of ergonomics

The Sword controller has a formed physique to carry comfortably within the arms, mixed with a gentle wrist strap to permit the controllers to be strapped to the arms. This appears to mix the texture of a Contact controller with the strapped-in sensation of the Index Controllers. At first, the straps felt slightly stiff, however quickly softened and have become extra snug.

To place the controllers on, you slide your arms into them and discover the hand straps. As soon as you might be gripping the controllers you possibly can simply modify the strap stress utilizing an adjuster constructed into the bottom of the controller physique and monitoring ring.

On the prime of the strap is a pivot mounted on a sprung, sliding piece that strikes backwards and forwards inside the sting of the controller physique. This pivot enable the angle of the strap to be set, it’s fairly agency so will maintain the angle you set regardless of hand motion. 

The decrease strap makes use of a pull-through clamp within the base of the monitoring ring. It’s a bit stiff to make use of however works and maintains a agency grip as soon as set, so it by no means got here unintentionally unfastened. Subsequent to the adjuster may be seen the USB port for doing firmware updates or charging the batteries while contained in the controllers.

The form of the Sword controller and the distinctive form of its hand strap with its personal adjustment vary signifies that it feels very completely different to the Index controller.

Index was the primary VR controller to ship with a dorsal retaining strap that many at the moment are turned onto, together with corporations making grips with straps for Meta controllers, and people making new controllers just like the Pimax Sword.

Because the ergonomics are very completely different, the controller acts in another way to Index when strapped onto the arms. For my medium-sized arms, it’s much less secure when ungripped: for instance, if throwing one thing like a grenade in a recreation, it is going to wobble barely while Index would keep caught to my hand.

The picture above reveals the distinction between the 2 controllers, if specializing in the distinction within the palmer (palm) and dorsal (again of hand) help of the arms. In each circumstances the palm rests towards the plastic physique (Index fitted with Palm booster right here), and the again of hand towards the material strap.

However the our bodies and straps have a really completely different form and orientation, Sword has a a lot smaller and shorter physique and this appears to be permitting my hand to maneuver barely because the decrease portion of my palm isn’t supported on the identical depth as throughout the center of the physique. Index’s help runs straight, beneath the top of the material strap, while the decrease third of Sword shortly curves away

I discovered this a part of my palm and medial border (facet of little finger) repeatedly got here into contact with the decrease tube a part of the Sword physique, letting my hand press towards the within of the monitoring ring which was really fairly snug. The dorsal strap isn’t unhealthy in any respect, it typically works in most video games and its significantly better than having no straps by way of consolation and immersion. 

I’ve discovered that with some software program functions it felt extra snug and immersive to run the straps unfastened with my hand holding the controller within the common means the place it feels much like Contact. This isn’t unusual, many gamers have their very own choice and usually maintain controllers in a barely completely different solution to what was supposed by the designer. Many Index gamers don’t like taking part in Beat Saber strapped in, however run the straps looser and have their very own hand pose.

One thing that was noticeable was not likely having wherever to relaxation your thumb as you don’t all the time wish to be contacting the trackpad, and making an attempt to help your thumb diagonally hits the Menu button. This was shortly skilled in Beat Saber with its excessive acceleration and stress loading as gamers spin their arms round: if I left my thumb on the trackpad, it continuously clicked resulting from controller motion as I swung my arms.

A pure resolution gave the impression to be wrapping my fingers across the facet of the controller head and under the set off for fast-moving video games like Beat Saber the place there is no such thing as a in-game interplay aside from bodily transferring the controller themselves. Later throughout my weeks of testing, I discovered a difficulty that developed maybe associated to fixed hand and monitoring ring interplay… you’ll learn extra on this later within the article.

As soon as strapped into Sword, rapid discover is given to the Trackpad, as your thumb falls naturally into place throughout the center of its floor, giving a pure resting place so long as trackpad interplay isn’t required.

The trackpad

Probably the most rapid function I examined after the monitoring rings was the trackpads. These have a mildly concave face that’s roughly 37mm in diameter, and a agency click on when depressed wherever throughout the face. 

With out pulling the controllers aside I couldn’t simply inform the place this had been sourced from, although it felt much like the trackpad used within the Vive controller and Steam controller. The Sword trackpad had a nice coating (unsure if it’s the identical coating used on the physique and ring) which supplied slight friction but in addition allowed easy motion, and labored effectively with sweaty arms.

As with many trackpads, there’s a click on when depressed, which is used for added enter: while taking part in “In Dying”, urgent down on the left trackpad brings up arrow choice while the trackpad itself can be utilized for sluggish free locomotion.

General I discovered the trackpad snug, straightforward to make use of, very intuitive, and an important match for my medium-sized arms. Nevertheless, its efficiency and helpful perform have been very software program dependent.

The Trackpad difficulty

This brings up a a lot larger difficulty, going again to the argument round free locomotion versus teleport, with joystick and trackpad sitting in opposing conerns.  I’m not right here to take sides on this debate, however to notice it as a real concern for a lot of gamers.

Free motion with the trackpad in many more moderen video games wasn’t conceptl, it felt unreliable by way of pace and course, and positively bought me killed extra continuously in Compound and Pavlov in comparison with utilizing a joystick based mostly controller. Used as teleport it was no downside, however this adjustments gameplay, immersion, and many others.

For older SteamVR functions (many from the sooner days of Vive PCVR), the touchpad is often the only option, as numerous these apps simply don’t work as effectively with joysticks in the case of teleportation. The brief vary of thumb motion on trackpad to activate teleport motion, in comparison with pushing the taller index stick ahead, was extra environment friendly and correct.

This was the most important take away concerning the touchpad, for teleportation it’s a lot simpler to make use of and extra correct. The small joystick on Index isn’t accurately aligned with the pure ahead attain of the hand, which may trigger teleportation (and free locomotion) to really feel misaligned with the supposed course of journey.

The Index stick can also be a bit small and mushy giving much less correct suggestions in comparison with a agency motion on the trackpad. Ought to Pimax have constructed a trackpad controller in 2022? A query I hope to reply a bit later.

Face Buttons

As talked about earlier, Pimax has shipped the Sword with a “lacking button” from the controller face, they’ve adopted the Vive controller template, so we have now simply two buttons: the “Menu” button and “Residence” button. The buttons themselves really feel good, the menu button is distinguished while the house button is recessed to stop unintentional engagement.

The buttons don’t have capacitive sensors, in contrast to the Meta and Index controllers, however this has restricted use in recreation so it’s not an enormous loss.  I discovered this fascinating data on Pimax’s weblog from September 2021:

In our efforts to optimize Capsense (particular person finger monitoring) functionality for our Sword of VR controllers we have now decided we won’t be able to realize the extent of compatibility we got down to accomplish and won’t embrace a Capsense functionality in our Sword Controllers. Different distinguished requests are so as to add a “B” button and a model with a joystick. Now we have determined to not create alternate variations of the Sword controller and can solely launch the trackpad model. We perceive a few of chances are you’ll be disenchanted with this resolution and we sincerely apologize to these of you interested by a joystick model.

The Menu button feels extra secure than the buttons on the Index which have been all the time a bit ‘wobbly’ with feeling of an excessive amount of lateral float. It’s additionally very straightforward to slip your thumb off the trackpad and onto the Menu button, decreasing effort within the recreation.

The shortage of the third button is one thing that’s seen in newer VR functions, and regardless of SteamVR’s absolutely customizable controller enter system, a lacking button remains to be a lacking button and due to this fact a missed alternative for additional inputs. Nevertheless, this was a limitation of utilizing the Vive driver in SteamVR and one thing outdoors of Pimax’s rapid management.

Set off

The triggers are giant moulded items with a curved form designed to assist the consumer find and retain the set off towards the set off finger. The motion of the triggers is probably slightly too deep earlier than activation, because it’s a easy swap in contrast to the dual-stage motion of the Index triggers. While the set off typically works as supposed, there have been 3 points I discovered that hindered gameplay:

• Free float. there appears to be extra journey earlier than activation. While this permits the consumer to drift the set off with out activation, it additionally makes for a slower pull motion, and might make the “set off level” much less dependable by way of hitting the identical depth every time. I’d wish to see this float diminished, or the inclusion of a journey adjuster to permit the consumer to setup the set off to go well with their arms and most well-liked fashion of play.

• Sensitivity. This may very well be associated to extra journey, however I discovered the set off overly delicate in some functions, taking pictures off a number of rounds with a single pull. This brought about issues in shooters the place ammo and accuracy is king. For functions the place the set off is used to activate a function or set off exercise, this wasn’t a difficulty. A later set of controllers exhibited much less of this behaviour, suggesting the software program is being improved.

• Form. Relying on the sport, frequency of set off use, size of your set off finger and pose the controller is held in, I seen a barely sharp edge throughout the vertical face of the set off, particularly towards both sides and the decrease edge. While this wasn’t uncomfortable by way of inflicting ache, it was noticeable in video games like House Pirate Coach and the Gunman Chronicles mod for Half Life Alyx the place I used to be doing a number of taking pictures. The continued sensation was of my finger resting towards a slight edge, fairly than the graceful face of a typical set off blade.

Grip Button

One of many massive issues with the outdated Vive controller was the facet grip buttons, which have been actually tough to undoubtedly use, however all too straightforward to unintentionally use. I had some leg buckling, and stomach-wrenching drops taking part in “Blue Shift” in 2016 on the Vive the place an unintentional press of the grip would trigger your pilot’s wings to retract, usually resulting in a crash into the ground.

Pimax has moved away from this, and adopted an identical fashion of facet grip button to Meta’s standard Contact controllers, amongst others. This grip button is a straightforward on/off mechanism: for instance, in Compound the controllers will keep caught to my arms till I click on the grip button. It’s additionally not capacitive, in contrast to the Meta Contact controllers.

Utilizing Index controllers, the squeeze to grip wasn’t as dependable in Compound, and if weapons weren’t firmly gripped when transitioning ranges I’d lose them and begin the following stage weaponless! The Sword feels higher on this respect, much less immersive however extra correct inflicting much less cognitive load when the fight will get intense.

General the Sword grip buttons really feel good to make use of with their easy on/off motion and slight float earlier than activation (not as deep because the triggers). Grip buttons really feel very completely different from Index’s grip sensors, will work higher for some functions and never as effectively for others. 

Relating to grip, the controllers have finger monitoring {hardware} already in-built. This has not been activated as a result of Pimax had points getting the SteamVR driver for Vive to work correctly. Extra on this later…

Haptics

From my expertise utilizing different controllers, it seems the Sword are utilizing a high-quality ERM (eccentric rotating mass) motors. It feels suitably punchy for functions Beat Saber and shooters, although not probably the most delicate by way of vary or quick response.

Having an excellent robust haptic motor is vital, some functions enable tuning of haptic power to let the participant set their consolation or suggestions stage.

Haptics drain battery energy, as is clear when taking part in Beat Saber the place the controllers are continuously firing their motors rewarding the participant with an excellent, strong expertise. That is in stark distinction to the weak haptics that have been discovered on the WMR controllers, so anemic that made Beat Saber really feel like a shadow of its regular self.

Coloured mild in entrance

The “respiratory mild” is an extended strip on the entrance fringe of the controller, and provides the three pairing states of crimson, blue, and inexperienced.

This mild will drain the battery barely faster than a single LED, and does trigger some native “mild air pollution”. For those who play in a totally darkened room, and your headset has a niche across the nostril or gasket edge, it may be slightly distracting.

However in any other case, the coloured mild seems fairly cool (it units the Pimax aside) and is beneficial when pairing at arm’s size (or with the headset on) fairly than searching for the small LED on the Index controllers. 

Capacitive sensing

As talked about within the buttons part, there is no such thing as a “cap” sense or capacitive sensing on Sword. Which means that holding a finger near the button or set off doesn’t register as on Index and Meta controllers. It often is a pleasant contact for hand presence however doesn’t actually have an effect on gameplay or present extra capabilities. The touchpad will register a really mild contact resulting from its sensitivity, but it surely’s not cap-equipped like the opposite buttons, both.

Monitoring

After attending to grips with the match and the management setup, I needed a better take a look at the monitoring setup hidden in these massive rings. 

Pimax has talked about utilizing an unprecedented 52 optical sensors for every Sword.  SteamVR beforehand had a tough restrict of 32 sensors per processor, to make use of extra you must run an extra processor which simply provides one other layer of complication, price, and elevated energy funds. Pimax additionally mentions utilizing a better specification IMU with a sooner knowledge seize fee.

What this all meant was very performant monitoring in any respect angles, which was very spectacular. Lowering the potential for occlusion is the large profit that the vertical peak and width of the monitoring rings present. I attempted holding a pistol in Pavlov with my proper hand and citing the left controller to regular the piston with my left hand, and I nonetheless had no points with monitoring occlusion.

There was additionally no bodily contact between the monitoring rings of each arms at any level, which was shocking contemplating the scale of the rings. Pimax stated they tried many iterations of the monitoring ring, and it reveals as a result of it really works effectively, it feels very balanced with the load of the controller physique and the monitoring ring felt across the wrist space and never onto the arms.

Throughout my weeks of testing, I had no points with monitoring, it was tremendous dependable and correct (Pimax declare 0.3mm)… the everyday SteamVR lighthouse efficiency. Was the monitoring higher than Index? Sure by way of occlusion, however in any other case no distinction in efficiency when ‘on beam’.

The JSON

Taking a better look below the hood, I downloaded “the JSON” from one of many Sword controllers and inspected it nearer. For those who perceive SteamVR gadgets, this may make rapid sense, in any other case consider it as the motive force containing what kind of system it’s, a calibrated digital illustration of the bodily geometry of the system and its optical sensors, the IMU orientation, calibration, and firmware references. That is what I discovered within the file:

{
   "device_class" : "controller",
   "device_pid" : 8960,
   "device_serial_number" : "LHR-3AAFE550",
   "device_vid" : 10462,
   "firmware_config" : {
      "mode" : "controller",
      "radio" : true,
      "spi_flash" : true,
      "trackpad" : true,
      "set off" : true,
      "vrc" : true
   },
   "head" : {
      "plus_x" : [ 1, 0, 0 ],
      "plus_z" : [ 0, 0, 1 ],
      "place" : [ 0, 0.014999999664723873, -0.039999999105930328 ]
   },
   "imu" : {
      "acc_bias" : [ -0.00695100008, 0.0625400022, 0.1074 ],
      "acc_scale" : [ 0.989000022, 1.01199996, 0.995199978 ],
      "gyro_bias" : [ -0.0315000005, -0.00493799988, 0.0119500002 ],
      "plus_x" : [ 0.21935559694180662, -0.10911204939182584, 0.9695244382583178 ],
      "plus_z" : [ -0.97563917749450069, -0.02111220658916535, 0.21836305462256833 ],
      "place" : [ 0.0017470000311732292, -0.00031425998895429075, 0.049129698425531387 ]
   },
   "lighthouse_config" : {
      "channelMap" : [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26 ],
      "modelNormals" : [
         [ -0.0380270146, -0.700318217, -0.712817252 ],
         [ 0.0247669965, -0.783519864, 0.620872915 ],
         [ -0.470197946, -0.682181954, 0.559947968 ],
         [ -0.823689103, -0.40073207, 0.401186049 ],
         [ 0.258702964, -0.635018945, -0.727889955 ],
         [ -0.9494645, 0.259356886, 0.176779911 ],
         [ 0.183486015, -0.198414028, -0.962790132 ],
         [ -0.774320185, 0.613231122, 0.156128034 ],
         [ -0.0412880108, 0.336935103, 0.940622211 ],
         [ -0.205230892, 0.746753633, 0.632644713 ],
         [ 0.497776866, -0.663111806, 0.559017897 ],
         [ 0.811035693, 0.584931791, -0.0087095676 ],
         [ -0.155315056, -0.113550037, -0.981317341 ],
         [ 0.410959989, 0.910741985, 0.0407560989 ],
         [ -0.446696937, 0.891022861, 0.0808706954 ],
         [ 0.315415144, 0.0470154211, -0.947788477 ],
         [ 0.886287987, -0.28452, 0.365433991 ],
         [ -0.364768982, -0.40288493, -0.839420855 ],
         [ 0.960236669, 0.249453917, 0.125372961 ],
         [ -0.183747053, 0.393173158, 0.900917292 ],
         [ -0.0172920022, 0.721602082, 0.692092061 ],
         [ -0.80495429, 0.470315188, -0.361735106 ],
         [ -0.82476598, -0.53570801, -0.181047007 ],
         [ 0.350825042, 0.221277028, -0.909922123 ],
         [ 0.819256008, 0.453711003, -0.350665003 ],
         [ 0.693582177, -0.608478129, 0.385614097 ]
      ],
      "modelPoints" : [
         [ -0.00322245085, -0.0423639342, 0.110276416 ],
         [ -0.0212385692, -0.0436412469, 0.121922232 ],
         [ -0.0512818396, -0.0405346937, 0.114965484 ],
         [ -0.0770718157, -0.0266842265, 0.0934347287 ],
         [ -0.0750427023, -0.0283354167, 0.0858111829 ],
         [ -0.0918799266, 0.0155795487, 0.0543927103 ],
         [ -0.0837710872, 0.0318264626, 0.0459391288 ],
         [ -0.0727503449, 0.0511742942, 0.0497174636 ],
         [ -0.0838254765, 0.0228967052, 0.0657553971 ],
         [ -0.0589980558, -0.0263176728, 0.113080822 ],
         [ 0.0107006812, -0.0333019644, 0.121234082 ],
         [ 0.0305221658, 0.0621658713, 0.0640221015 ],
         [ 0.0237923265, 0.0585589409, 0.0588182583 ],
         [ 0.00169629336, 0.0878300071, 0.0609984286 ],
         [ -0.0308794323, 0.0856003016, 0.0576769523 ],
         [ -0.0480047278, 0.0697084963, 0.0494043864 ],
         [ 0.0450265184, -0.0139670018, 0.0896124169 ],
         [ 0.0480728894, 0.00653656898, 0.0723890886 ],
         [ 0.0495340265, 0.0231161006, 0.0745737925 ],
         [ 0.0440835729, 0.0192563497, 0.0851787925 ],
         [ 0.0298181251, -0.0146432128, 0.107967824 ],
         [ -0.0288773328, -0.00125610933, -0.0075312932 ],
         [ -0.0265464336, -0.0105262389, -0.0109835137 ],
         [ 0.0107968682, -0.00717549631, -0.0275005642 ],
         [ 0.029771477, 0.000665576779, -0.00721752411 ],
         [ 0.0224537514, -0.0124576362, 0.00857212581 ]
      ]
   },
   "producer" : "HTC",
   "model_number" : "Pimax Left",
   "render_model" : "{aapvr}sword_handler_1_0_left",
   "resource_root" : "aapvr",
   "revision" : 2,
   "tracked_controller_role" : "left_hand"
}

Testing with standard software program

To place Sword by their paces I did a number of testing in standard software program I’ve been beforehand utilizing with Index controllers. I used to be to strive the trackpads in older software program and present software program which is concentrating on joystick-based customers.

SteamVR Residence in fact felt nice nonetheless being a teleportation-based surroundings, and I had way more enjoyable transferring about fluidly and precisely with the Sword’s trackpads. The Index sticks don’t all the time align along with your supposed course of teleport placement, whereas the trackpads simply labored nice as all the time.

Immediately these controllers felt like an important match for Beat Saber, so I performed much more Beat Saber than I’ve in months, regardless of the two heatwaves that hit the UK through the testing interval. I by no means discovered the Index controllers nice for Beat Saber, all the time preferring the older Vive controllers with their “easy held software” form.

Regardless of my greatest efforts to frantically wave my arms round, Sword by no means misplaced monitoring in Beat Saber, simply felt very exact and dependable like most SteamVR gear.

Testing included hanging out and transferring round in SteamVR residence environments, utilizing VR Chat, intense gunfights in “Pavlov”, combating ever upwards by the company world of “Compound”…

… a number of firing quick arrows “In Dying”, wandering by completely different ranges of “Half Life Alyx” and the superb chapter 1 of the “Gunman Chronicles” mod. Basic House Pirate Coach repeatedly featured, the room-scale nature and frantic gameplay working effectively with Sword. In “Pistol Whip”, although, that slight edge to the set off made longer classes much less snug on my set off finger.

Shockingly, I most well-liked HLA with the touchpad and teleportation. I wasn’t an enormous fan of the free locomotion mode which was clearly built-in at a later stage of growth and didn’t work so nice with the Index’s underbaked joystick and sluggish locomotion tempo. The usage of teleport to clear gaps or drops pressured free locomotion customers to teleport, which left the entire thing really feel a bit combined up and fewer immersive for me.  

With Sword, I may shortly transfer by an space with correct teleportation after which deal with shut element and fight utilizing roomscale. The teleport felt way more correct with the trackpad, while Valve’s help of various controllers meant no downside assigning inputs as required.

My favourite single-player recreation “In Dying” is all the time a brutal check of monitoring accuracy, controller sturdiness, and enter choices, and the Sword dealt with themselves effectively. The arrow pushed teleport mechanism means no trackpad or stick motion is required for distance journey, although the trackpad’s free locomotion motion wasn’t as correct because the Index’s joystick on this specific recreation, making creeping about much less enjoyable because it was a bit cease and begin. Vertical arrow pictures within the second stage have been dealt with with no loss in monitoring accuracy.  Haptics felt robust and punchy, making for excellent feeling “defend bash” melée motion.

And naturally, I performed tons and many “Beat Saber” the place I began getting larger scores while progressing by numerous Skilled+ ranges I’d not have the ability to clear with Index controllers.

The Pimax controllers felt actually good in Beat Saber, and I discovered myself actually having fun with the expertise much more than utilizing my Index controllers. The Sword controllers have a very impartial steadiness level, punchy haptics, and an excellent strong really feel within the arms, even when run with looser straps.

After some intensive testing, I began to note a slight motion someplace within the decrease a part of the controller. Ignoring this because it was very slight, I had one other Beat Saber session earlier than noticing the motion was changing into extra pronounced. Stopping, I checked out the controllers and seen that the mechanical becoming / interface between the monitoring ring and the controller physique had developed some free play, or slop. Fastidiously holding the controllers, I may transfer the lengthy base of the physique backwards and forwards towards the monitoring ring.

I instantly contacted Pimax, and was despatched a alternative set of Sword controllers as a complicated alternative, and supplied with free return delivery which is fulfilled by Amazon within the UK. The alternative controllers arrived earlier than I’d even had an opportunity to discover a native UPS workplace for the return, for an total very spectacular customer support!

Since getting the alternative controllers I’ve continued testing as shortly as potential to see if I may replicate the difficulty. After two weeks of testing, the issue hasn’t reoccurred, however I’d been taking part in so much much less Beat Saber which gave the impression to be the perpetrator with its excessive velocities and stresses.

For instance, Valve needed to rework their monitoring software program after they discovered gamers have been utilizing movement controllers at a lot larger speeds than was ever anticipated, which demonstrates what an excellent check the sport is for {hardware}.

Pimax is conscious of the difficulty I discovered, and has obtained my broken controllers for inspection. I’m not a mechanical engineer but it surely appears to make sense to bolster this space to stop loosening sooner or later. The strain from my decrease hand towards the monitoring ring wasn’t serving to.

Pimax Sword are completely different in that the controller ring and physique are 2 items fastened with a mechanical connection, whereas most controllers use a 1 piece design. My suggestion concerned reinforcing this space to preempt any future issues as stronger or extra aggressive gamers could encounter this difficulty sooner. 

I used to be impressed with Pimax’s response, and their willingness to enhance their gear bodes effectively for his or her future! Because the king of Index controllers’ RMAs, I’m eager to see how my new Sword controllers maintain up, and whether or not the issue will re-occur.

Interview with Kevin Henderson

After spending some weeks with Sword, and earlier than making my conclusions, I needed to know extra about them, so I managed to seize a brief interview with Kevin Henderson, Pimax’s COO.

From LinkedIn: “Senior government with over 29 years of expertise in worldwide enterprise, product growth, and growth of outstanding gross sales channels. A wonderful observe file and sometimes called a jack of all trades for conceptualizing new superior merchandise, growing the manufacturing, packaging, distribution channels, and authorized work. My present place is COO and firm spokesperson for Pimax VR.”

I wish to thank so much Kevin for the time he has devoted to answering my questions and giving me extra particulars concerning the Sword controllers.

Closing ideas and thanks

This has been one of the vital fascinating opinions for me, as a result of I’d heard a lot about Pimax however not had the boldness to strive their {hardware} partly resulting from all of the earlier noise across the Kickstarter, and partly a reluctance to purchase {hardware} instantly from producers.

The retail partnership with Amazon would alleviate my latter concern, as a daily Amazon buyer, this fills me with confidence. I’ve already used this mechanism to purchase and return an costly Vive Professional 2 headset final 12 months.

It’s very straightforward to observe the favored opinion and dismiss Pimax as lower than credible, however that’s not been my expertise right here both from preliminary contact, responsiveness to questions, tremendous slick RMA course of, and willingness to tackle my findings and enhance the product (others may study from this!)

The Sword controllers are literally an excellent effort, they really feel good within the arms, regardless of missing joysticks and the additional button. For suitable software program (older teleportation titles, primarily) they’re an important selection, usually higher than Index. For newer titles, many have completely different motion choices so it’s potential to tweak issues to your liking.

The buttons labored and continued to work throughout my testing. The set off developed no squeaking or graunching (I’m my Index controllers right here!), the trackpad simply labored, and saved working, though my check wasn’t lengthy sufficient to find out if it may develop the identical difficulty that plagued my Vive controllers.

The monitoring is superb, occlusion is minimized in any respect angles and hand poses I may maneuver myself into. Battery life is workmanlike at 3 hours, and since these batteries are detachable they are often swapped in seconds for a contemporary pair. If the batteries turn out to be depleted by repeated use it’s no difficulty, simply swap in some new batteries and begin once more.

I’m seeing rising numbers of Index house owners with depleted batteries, and a few inventive options from the group to unravel this downside, together with one consumer who strapped a battery to the surface of the physique with wires working inside.

Opening up an Index controller to interchange a battery may be very tough, it wasn’t designed to be rebuildable. Pimax scores on this respect with its detachable battery design. The one draw back is a shorter run time, however 3 hours remains to be lots, and as I’ve stated, a fast swap out and also you’ve bought one other 3 hours of playtime.

Going again to my early questions

May this new controller from Pimax present a extra reasonably priced various to the easy but strong Vive controllers?

Sure, they supply the identical performance by way of software program parity, however with higher grip buttons, snug hand straps, an important trackpad, and wonderful monitoring. I didn’t get to check them for lengthy sufficient to search out out if the trackpad would possibly degrade like used to occur on the Vive controller requiring customers to open them up and shim them.

The Sword controllers are additionally extra reasonably priced than the Vive controllers, although solely accessible as a pair (Pimax may take a look at supplying particular person left/proper controllers like HTC and Valve).

May these present a extra strong various to the reasonably priced, however comparatively fragile Index controllers?

Initially, I’d have stated sure, however now I droop my judgment due to the difficulty with the mechanical connection between the monitoring ring and controller physique. Nevertheless, this ought to be fairly straightforward to resolve, and with Pimax’s engineers already trying into this, I’m positive it will likely be resolved earlier than many extra gamers get their arms on Sword controllers.

By way of enter sturdiness, the Sword controllers didn’t begin to degrade like a lot of my Index controllers had, though a typical downside for Index was joystick drift, and clearly not having joysticks means Sword avoids this specific difficulty, on the expense of free locomotion help.

Additionally, not having a joystick means nothing to snag on pockets of pants and snap off, and that is good for Beat Saber once more…

It was pleasantly quiet with out squeaking triggers (Index) and neither the set off blades on Sword nor the buttons began to wobble (Index) ,in order that’s an enormous bonus.

So ought to I purchase them?

This actually comes all the way down to the video games you play, and the way you wish to play them. With SteamVR having a extremely configurable enter setup, there are a lot of methods to configure your controllers.

Individuals even have their very own preferences, I’m one of many lesser few that also just like the Vive wand and suppose it’s nice selection for location-based venues the place onboarding is minimal or typically non-existent.

The Vive controller has a “right here maintain this, press right here” simplicity which Sword in some methods loses in just by having the massive monitoring rings and hand straps which generally is a little complicated for first-timers.  However as soon as fitted, they’re straightforward to make use of with a significantly better grip button which after the difficulty of trackpad sturdiness, was the most important grievance concerning the unique Vive “wand”.

With Sword missing the additional face button, you might be lacking one other enter component, however that extremely configurable setup in SteamVR means there are workarounds to get it arrange in a good means.

The difficulty of joysticks, finger monitoring help, and even that “lacking button” is a direct results of utilizing the Vive driver in SteamVR, and there isn’t a means round that till the system architect (Valve) offers extra help. For those who research “the JSON” of an Index controller, you see that Index may be very completely different from Vive, with Index controllers utilizing a wealth of customized firmware developed by Valve themselves.

SteamVR builders would possibly inform you that it’s a little bit of a “black field”, so growing new controllers isn’t wherever as easy as gamers would possibly suppose, the Vive and Index templates can be found plus some open supply drivers which may be tailored you probably have the ability. 

Personally, I like these controllers and loved taking part in video games like Beat Saber, Pistol Whip, House Pirate Coach, and Half-Life Alyx with them. The largest power of SteamVR is the ecosystem, letting you combine and match controllers. There’s nothing to cease you from utilizing Vive, Sword, and Index controllers in your system. You may even select a distinct controller for every hand for those who like.

My feeling with Sword is that Pimax will proceed to enhance them, the set off form (barely sharp) is a straightforward repair, if I had purchased them myself I’d have simply taken some effective moist and dry sandpaper to them to easy out the set off blade form. Pimax is conscious of sensitivity points with the set off, and the surplus set off journey: these are enhancements that aren’t tough to implement when you have got onshore manufacturing services.

My takeaway? A great first effort, that may solely get higher with additional growth. And sure, I plan to get a pair to enrich my Index controllers, that’s about the perfect endorsement I could make right here. There is perhaps a difficulty with the mechanical connection between the physique and ring, but it surely hasn’t occurred once more, but. Nevertheless, Pimax’s guarantee backup was very fast and hassle-free, offering new controllers earlier than I’d even shipped my originals again, prime marks for customer support.

Nevertheless, I gained’t be taking part in some video games with them (primarily those based mostly on free locomotion), however there’s loads of good software program that works higher with trackpads, and for that, Sword is effectively price . It’s lso the only option for individuals who simply favor teleport/blink motion.

For Beat Saber fanatics it is a nice selection, higher than Vive controller by way of monitoring and weight steadiness, however let’s see how Pimax reinforce that mechanical connection as Beat Saber is understood to push controllers (and gamers) to their limits.

I’m very to see what Pimax does subsequent, each by way of refining Sword, and manufacturing their new Crystal and 12K headsets. They’ve already supplied me a Crystal headset to check, as soon as the self-assembly equipment is launched… so sit up for a future check right here on Skarredghost.com.

Thanks for studying! Rob Cole

(Header picture supplied by Rob Cole)

Associated