What To Do When Gamers Miss The Clues?

Roleplaying Suggestions Publication #1193

(Be a part of the conversion about the following pointers on this thread at Marketing campaign Neighborhood.)

Hi there Sojourner!

That is Jonathan with www.sojournersawake.com.

Apart from the widespread journey in leaving city, delving into the dungeon, and slaying the monster to gather the reward, recreation masters can homebrew adventures involving thriller and discovery.

I take pleasure in tales of courageous explorers who get hold of misplaced lands, grapple with harmful relics, and resolve homicide mysteries.

However what do you do if the gamers roll low of their search?

Or what if the gamers fail to catch on to your artful description and miss the clues?

Listed below are 3 strategies you can begin utilizing to maintain the sport shifting.

Excessive Quantity Winner

Gamers usually describe their character actions, after which the sport grasp asks for a cube verify to find out success.

Nevertheless, when fixing mysteries, the motion could be occupied with the best answer.

To simulate this considering motion, I’ll name for a information verify from every participant after they enter a particular location the place the clue could be found.

The participant with the very best cube roll “wins” the information and might then take motion or share with the staff.


The sojourners arrive on the base of the mountain and arrange camp.

The clue on the way to enter lies earlier than them as a riddle to reply.

This idea is overseas to the characters since they’ve been utilizing bodily keys to enter locations.

So the gamers use all the standard strategies and discover that this entrance is a thriller. The gamers point out their characters “suppose” up the answer.

I name for a information verify and grant the very best roll the clue.

Surprisingly, the brute PC, IronTooth, scores the very best quantity.

I describe to IronTooth phrases on the wall that seem like markings he’s seen within the wizard PC’s journal.

For the reason that occasion beforehand missed this clue, I’m nonetheless leaving the destiny within the fingers of IronTooth. How they proceed is as much as them.

“Look” grunts IronTooth, “Quill has been writing on this wall.” He motions towards the writing.

Now the occasion has gained a clue.

Excessive Quantity Winner can be utilized to simulate information recall and discovering clues.

Reward System

Quite than inserting your discoveries in fastened areas inside your world, deal with them as cell rewards for the gamers after they set off an encounter.


The sojourners scour the brand new planet.

After saving a younger alien, the sport grasp rewards with a discovery of a brand new language.

Every participant positive aspects expertise with this ability.

After surviving the waterfall, the sport grasp rewards with discovering a brand new supply of energy on the backside of the river and every participant positive aspects a magical useful resource.

After efficiently negotiating with a hungry predator, the sport grasp rewards with discovering a ruined lore stone that tells every the historical past of this forgotten world.

Maintain the discoveries cell so you possibly can reward your gamers on the opportune time, all whereas protecting the story dynamic.

Join the Dots

You should use mysteries like the way in which you utilize monsters in your recreation: there could be some ways to resolve the thriller.

Gamers search the manor for clues on who killed the girl of the home.

As recreation grasp, you’ve an concept as to who did it and the way they did it.

However you retain the reply malleable because of this: the gamers would possibly generate a greater concept.


The sojourners hear of the homicide and determine to go looking the home up and down for clues.

They suppose the butler, chef, and coachman appear suspicious.

The gamers focus on amongst themselves and conclude every has a motive, however the coachman is most certainly and will have hid the physique within the storage.

The overall vibe of the desk is worked up with this concept, so that you determine to go alongside and join the dots of the gamers’ actions to the plot of the story.

This technique is collaborative, so hold your story free-form with room to improvise.

In case your gameplay relies upon upon discovering a clue or making a discovery, then the sport dangers screeching to a halt if gamers miss out on them, on account of poor cube rolls, or from low participation.

Use these three tricks to hold the gameplay shifting:

  • Excessive Quantity Winner
  • Reward System
  • Join the Dots

Might your story proceed!

Temporary Phrase From Johnn

A false spring sprang right here in Beaumont final week. It bought heat (solely -4), sunny, and melty.

I’m attempting to warn people new to city that it’s simply Room III: Trick and Setback.

As a result of the groundhog doesn’t lie and extra winter’s coming.

However methinks inevitable frozen tears of disappointment shall nonetheless roll forth down crimson cheeks quickly.

Meantime, I wished to name out a incredible challenge that Stephan Hornick is operating at Marketing campaign Neighborhood.

He’s porting over previous Roleplaying Suggestions newsletters, including enjoyable polls, and stirring up some nice discussions.

This challenge is free and open to you.

Be at liberty to swing by, learn some nice ideas, vote, and be part of the dialogue together with your fellow RPT GMs.

Have an excellent week. And attempt to get some gaming accomplished whereas winter wends onward!



Talk about these recreation grasp ideas on this thread on the official Roleplaying Suggestions neighborhood discussion board.


Latest articles

Related articles

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here